Julie & Andy in Carillon Beach, FL

Julie thought she was just going to a party with a few friends when she met Andy in 2003. After most guests had left, a small group gathered in the kitchen. Ironically, they ended up discussing the pros and cons of marriage. I was a believer and Andy was a skeptic! Julie says. Despite their difference in opinion about tying the knot, the mismatched group of friends hit it off and decided to all hang out again. One night, while out at their favorite restaurant, Andy forgot to get his keys from the valet before it closed. Julie still thinks he did it on purpose, because with no car, she had no choice but to invite him to crash on her couch. The Bride MiYong Julie Pak, 30, auditor The Groom Andrew Andy Davies, 33, software sales The Date May 3 Three years later, Andy proposed while the couple was on vacation in Puerto Rico. Julie and Andy credit their friends Deron and Ian with introducing them, but they're not the only ones. Julie's maid of honor, Amy, met Andy's best man, Alan, at the very same party five years ago and they are now engaged. Talk about a successful night out!