Kate & Tom in Chicago, IL

Kate and Tom both went to the University of Dayton, but didn't connect until post-graduation. Kate ran into some college buddies at a bar in Lincoln Park, Tom among them. He expressed interest through a mutual friend, and once he got the green light, they struck up a conversation...and a serious spark. The Bride Kate Wanzer, 29, attorney The Groom Tom Derhake, 30, consultant The Date October 6 Five years later, Tom got a ring and made his move. He asked Kate to go kayaking in Chicago. However, his romantic plan hit a snag that would have derailed a less-determined man: The river ran by a waste management facility, and the overpowering stench together with the sight of dead fish, dirty diapers, and even a dead duck had Kate in tears, asking to go home. When they got back, Tom quickly came up with a new plan: champagne at The Peninsula Bar, followed by dinner at The Custom House. When she dropped her napkin after the meal, he seized the moment to drop to one knee and propose.