Emerald Cut Engagement Ring in Massachusetts

When Corey was picking out Susan’s engagement ring, he accidentally took one of Susan’s pinky rings to get sized. When he went to place the ring on her finger, it didn’t fit. “This didn’t stop me from wearing the ring anyway,” Susan says. “Everyone said, ‘Let me see the ring!’ and there it was, on my pinky finger.”

MORE PHOTOS LIKE THIS

Rustic Ring Box With Moss Bed

Blue Cocktail Ring Family Tradition

Round Diamond Engagement Ring With Asscher Halo

Round Diamond Ring in Colorful Bouquet

Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring

Round Cut Engagement Ring with Halo and an Encrusted Band

April and Robert's Wedding Rings in Lubbock, Texas

Round Engagement Ring in Sunflower

Pear Shaped Diamond Ring with Graduating Diamond Setting

Cushion Cut Diamond Ring with Halo

Classic Custom Wedding Bands

Round Diamond Engagement Ring with Diamond Halo

Vintage Engagement Ring and Rose Gold Band

Rose and White Gold Wedding Bands

Diamond-Shaped Engagement Ring in Minnesota

Engagement Ring and Wedding Rings in Santa Rosa, California

Gold Invitation Suite With Wedding Rings

Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

Wedding Rings on 'Up'-Inspired Adventure Book

Solitaire Diamond Engagement Ring

Black and White Diamond Groom's Wedding Band

Kate and Stephanie Engagement Rings