Diane & Jeffrey in Cinnaminson, NJ

Even though Diane met Jeffrey in the first grade, it wasn’t until 16 years later when they were both living in New York City that the two reconnected -- and Diane realized she still had a crush on him after all those years! They soon started dating, and three years later, Jeffrey invited Diane to move to London with him. She accepted, and took a job with Peggy Porschen, a top wedding cake designer. The Bride Diane Lesser, 29, pastry chef The Groom Jeffrey Fehder, 29, photojournalist The Date March 21 After five months, they returned home, and Jeffrey asked Peggy to bake a wedding cake cookie with “Will you marry me?” written in icing. On Christmas Eve, he got down on one knee and revealed the cookie to Diane -- and then pulled out a ring. The couple opted for a burgundy-and-yellow color palette for their formal wedding