Vintage Pearl Bracelet

In addition to blue crystal earrings and vintage pearl bracelets, the pair accessorized their all-white looks with matching pairs of red heels for the reception. "We spent the month leading up to the wedding wearing our heels around the apartment in an effort to break them in," Allison says. "This earned us some strange looks when we walked our dog at night—bedazzled shoes and pajama pants aren't an everyday sight!"

More Photos From This Album

Ivory Knee-Length Wedding Dresses

Pink and Red Heart-Themed Escort Card Display

Pink Mailbox Guest Book

Catholic-Jewish Fusion Wedding at 501 Union

Red and Pink Floral Centerpieces

White Cupid's Arrow Wedding Cake

Hot Chocolate Drink Station

Matching White Gold Engagement Rings

"Nice Shot Cupid" Easy Paper Banner

Gold-Framed Valentine's Day Postcards

Gold-Framed Chair Signs

Brooklyn's 501 Union Wedding Reception

Pink and Red Photo Booth Props

Traditional Jewish Hora Dance

White Knee-Length Nicole Miller Wedding Dress

Brides in White Lace Wedding Dresses

Brooklyn Wedding Ceremony at 501 Union

Gold Chiavari Chairs at 501 Union Wedding Reception

Valentine's Day-Themed Menus

Red Mug Wedding Favors