Victoria & John in Rochester, MN

Though they were on the same three-pitch baseball team in the third grade and grew up less than a mile apart, Victoria and John never really got to know each other. Years later, while attending college at the University of Minnesota, they were reacquainted by mutual friends. They dated four years before John proposed on a Saturday, while sharing a romantic meal at home. The Bride Victoria Aksamit, 27, a graphic designer The Groom John Prendergast, 27, a life insurance product specialist The Date August 1 “It was actually Sweetest Day in October,” says Victoria. “I was totally surprised and thought, ‘Are you doing this now?’” she says. Then John pulled a box out of his sock and showed her the ring. “I realized it was for real and cried,” says Victoria.

MORE PHOTOS LIKE THIS

Jennifer & Toby in Mackinac Island, MI

Lindsay & Taylor in Woody Creek, CO

Colleen & Joe in Queenstown, MD

Christie & Brian in St. Charles, IL

Holly & Matt in Seaside, FL

Erica & Don in Ipswich, MA

Julia & Michael in Pittsburgh, PA

Kristyn & Chris in San Antonio, TX

Jessica & Michael in Breckenridge, CO

Amber & Mark in Divide, CO

Andrea & Samir in Bretton Woods, NH

Hadley & Edouard in Louveciennes, France

Carly & Daniel in New York City, NY

Yoko & Sean in Lancaster, PA

Jessica & Doug in Cochranville, PA

Amy & Greg in Austin, TX

Riki & Will in Cave Creek, AZ

Olivia & Rich in Windham, NH

Catherine & Jonathan in Vancouver, British Columbia

Jen & Mike in Sparta, NJ

Deborah & Jay in Boston, MA

Lindsay & Michael in Bedford, PA