Robyn & Jeff in La Jolla, CA

The first time Jeff wanted to propose to Robyn, they were in La Jolla to see a friend who was performing in a play. Unfortunately, the ring wasn't ready. Worse, the hotel never got the message that the proposal was postponed, and they had already upgraded the couple to the presidential suite. Still, the weekend wasn't a total loss as Robyn fell in love with the hotel and knew it was where she wanted to be married. The Bride Robyn Goldberg, 40, wedding planner The Groom Jeff Maynard, 38, theater teacher The Date November 1 Jeff managed to outdo himself a second time by totally surprising Robyn on their one-year anniversary with dinner at the Bel Air Hotel and a proposal in a rose petal and candle-filled bungalow.