Reagan & Anthony in Bee Cave, TX

Reagan first caught Anthony's attention during a Secret Santa exchange. The two worked together, and when Anthony found out Reagan got her Secret Santa a Sports Illustrated Swimsuit calendar and homemade chocolate chip cookies, he was hooked. Fast-forward to the following Christmas, when Reagan and Anthony -- by now an item -- were spending the night wrapping holiday gifts for children and families in need. The Bride Reagan Nunnally, 33, agency leader The Groom Anthony Napolitano, 29, team leader The Date December 1 Anthony had picked up the engagement ring earlier that day and planned to give it to Reagan that evening, but wrapping presents took a little longer than he thought. The couple didn't get home until nearly 2 a.m.! After what felt like an eternity, he finally got his shot and proposed in front of the Christmas tree.