Lisa & John in Old Bridge, NJ

Lisa and John met briefly at a mutual friend’s birthday party. A few months later, they bonded at a New Year’s Eve over a love of Pulp Fiction. Their first date happened accidentally: John invited a handful of friends to see a movie but only Lisa was free to join him. The Bride Lisa Gadaleta, 29, a graphic designer The Groom John Bihuniak, 27, a distribution supervisor The Date May 9 Almost three years later, they returned to that same theater and John asked Lisa to take a seat on a nearby bench. He leaned in toward her (she thought he was going in for a kiss on the cheek!), reached into his pocket for a princess-cut diamond ring and proposed.