Kelly & Farzeen in Huntington, NY

After two years of dating, Kelly and her boyfriend Farzeen took a trip to St. Barths together. While shopping, they stopped off in a store to try on rings, and one in particular caught Kelly's eye. The Bride Kelly Garrett, 33, physician The Groom Farzeen Firoozi, 34, physician The Date May 12 Having had such a good time on their trip, the couple went back three months later. Once they settled into their villa, they decided to take a walk on the beach. As the sun was setting, Farzeen dropped to one knee and proposed with a ring that looked exactly like the one Kelly had tried on the previous year -- Farzeen had taken a picture of the ring and had it custom-made. Obviously, I said yes, Kelly says.