Jen & Marco in Katonah, NY

Part of the same psychology graduate class, Jen and Marco started seeing each other when a group of classmates began a series of pick-up soccer games. After four years of dating, Marco had planned to propose to Jen outside her house (where they had shared their first kiss), and then whisk her away in a limo ride for a romantic getaway in Manhattan. The Bride Jen Rosenblatt, 31, a post-doctoral fellow in child psychology The Groom Marco DiBonaventura, 29, a researcher for a healthcare research and consulting firm The Date June 6 Marco made an excuse to get Jen out of the house (so he could pop the question on the way back in), but when they returned, the limo was already there, 30 minutes early. Marco had to rush through the proposal on top of the limo driver obliviously, and loudly, chatting on his phone outside the car. Still, Jen says, “We were engaged, so to me, it was perfect.”