Deborah & Jay in Boston, MA

Deborah agreed to go to a Halloween party with her friend during her sophomore year at Brown University. Little did she know that she was about to meet the man she’d marry, Jay, who was also studying at Brown at the time. With Deborah in a Charlie’s Angel costume and Jay dressed as the Monopoly Man, the costumed pair hit it off and started dating. The Bride Deborah Witzburg, 26, a law student The Groom Jay Beidler, 27, an investment analyst The Date August 15 Just over five years later, Jay asked Deborah out to dinner, and placed a small, black velvet box on the table. When she opened it, she found the engagement ring that once belonged to her great-great grandmother.