Catherine & Andrew in Torch Lake, MI

A friend of Andrew suggested he ask out Catherine after the friend heard Catherine speak in one of her classes. Sparks flew when, after a little finagling, a setup was arranged. The pair moved in together two-and-a-half years later. A year-and-a-half after that, they had already ordered an engagement ring. The Bride Catherine Stellin, 35, in entertainment marketing The Groom Andrew Waller, 33, film director The Date July 19 Right before Andrew and Catherine left on a 10-day Thanksgiving vacation to Hawaii, Catherine told Andrew not to propose during the trip. She thought that waiting for the moment would be too stressful for both of them. Andrew agreed, but proposed to Catherine anyway on Thanksgiving morning on the Maui cliffs.