Brooke & Ian in Alexandria, VA

Now here's a sweet proposal: After meeting on Match.com, Ian planned on popping the question to Brooke with her favorite food -- ice cream! The Bride Brooke Warner, 30, high school teacher The Groom Ian Walsh, 32, technology coordinator The Date June 16 Ian packed a picnic with two pints of Ben & Jerry's. One was Chocolate Fudge Brownie, while the other, decorated with photos of the couple, contained the engagement ring. Brooke opted for Chocolate Fudge Brownie and wasn't even interested in seeing the other flavor. Ian finally convinced me to look, and inside, the new flavor was called Brooke and Ian's True Love, she remembers. I'm really glad I looked! Brooke is from Virginia and Ian from Maryland, so the two chose to stay near home for their wedding.